Review: Holy Cow!

Holy Cow! by Harry Caray
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I read Carey’s “Holy Cow!” right after reading the book about him read by his long-time on-air partner Steve Stone “Where’s Harry?”. I recommend reading these together. Steve includes many of the same stories as Harry, but they are obviously told from an outsiders perspective. When you read Harry’s story, you understand what Harry wants you to understand about his life. The persona that he built over the years is on display here – Harry being the voice of the fans, Harry partying it up all night, Harry shilling for his friends and his oft-times beer sponsors. Harry also explains his rise through radio in Joliet and Kalamazoo, working there with Paul Harvey. The stories of his early life focus on the drive Caray had to become a sportscaster, and it is a surprisingly motivating story. But overall, you get from Harry that he dedicated himself to broadcasting, above all else including family. But from Stone, you get the sense that there also lurks a genius behind Harry’s rise, and sometimes it is an evil genius, or at least a remarkably self-centered genius. Stone illustrates the reasons behind some of the things that Harry did, things that added to his fame and tenure. Taking Stone’s book along with this book of Harry’s together, you get a much more complex idea of who Harry Caray was, and in my mind that make’s him a much more interesting person.
By the way, Goodreads suggests that the 5 books most similar to “Holy Cow!” are all horror books, four by Stephen King. I’ll need time to process this….


View all my reviews

Review: Battle Cry: Waging and Winning the War Within

Battle Cry: Waging and Winning the War Within by Jason Wilson
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

“Battle Cry” provides living-your-life advice to men, given plentiful stories of the author’s life and scripture. I found the author’s perspective to be the draw here, as he talks about growing up and living in the mean streets of Detroit, being a janitor in a school, running a martial arts school and learning martial arts, and being a non-profit founder. And he provides learning anecdotes from his family life, without sugar coating the bad. His advice is simple and not all that surprising. I felt the author leaned on scripture quotes a bit too often, given his life story seemed so interesting. Overall, “Battle Cry” had flashes of interesting stories, but felt a bit generic in the bible-based life advice provided.

View all my reviews

Review: Sackett

Sackett by Louis L'Amour
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I purchased a number of Louis L’Amour books recently, thinking I might try reading the kind of books my Dad read growing up. I asked one of my best friends from high school, who was always reading a L’Amour paperback, which one he’d suggest I read first, as I hadn’t read but a few. He told me his favorite was “Sackett”, and since that was in the bundle I purchased, I read it first. I’ve only read a handful of Westerns, mostly Zane Grey’s. There seemed to be a kind of formula, where the lone cowboy hero of the story was the silent, surprisingly smart fellow who appreciates the land and tries to do the right thing by his people and society. In “Sackett” we have a hero with attributes in multiple areas, many more than other Western heroes that I have read. Sackett is superhumanly strong, exceptionally smart (book smart as well as nature smart, and always learning), tall, sense of humor, head for business, strong moral and family code, handsome to the ladies. He’s pretty much a Western super hero. I didn’t get the impression anything could stop him, outside of horrible blizzards or a lucky shot from a mile away. (Ends up he’s only slowed down by these kinds of things.)

Once I got into the superhero mode, this ended up being a good read. I look forward to reading more, and seeing if the Sackett’s great genes exist in others of the family.


View all my reviews

Review: Why Fish Don't Exist: A Story of Loss, Love, and the Hidden Order of Life

Why Fish Don't Exist: A Story of Loss, Love, and the Hidden Order of Life by Lulu Miller
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I hadn’t heard of David Starr Jordan prior to reading this book, so I found his story quite fascinating. If the book was about him, I would have enjoyed it. I even enjoyed the scheme the writer used to tell his story in the order in which she learned it, where Jordan goes from good and industrious to ethically questionable. But this becomes a parallel memoir of the author and her relationships. If the author lowered the memoir quotient I would have appreciated this one more. The writing mostly maintained my interest, and the fish story is quite interesting.

View all my reviews

Review: The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay

The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay by Michael Chabon
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I enjoyed following Kavalier and Clay as they entered the nascent comics business just before WWII, built their art and their business, and lived their lives with a worldview built on the ethics of superhero comics, and also the ethics of business. It is a long book, longer than I tend to read. But, unlike many other reviewers, I didn’t feel the length was beyond what was needed. Then again, I listened to this on audio at high speed, so perhaps that helped… I mostly enjoyed the description of the times and the places the story takes place. I also liked reading about the comics business and how the companies were developed – this seems very true to history. I also enjoyed the description of the apprenticeship of a magician. Least enjoyable were some of the plot twists in the last third of the book that seemed too over the top. Overall, though, I did enjoy this one.

View all my reviews

Review: The Philosophy of Modern Song

The Philosophy of Modern Song by Bob Dylan
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

Quite an odd book, especially on audio. Dylan picks about 50 pop songs from the 20s to the 90s or so, songs that he likes. For many of them, he does a kind of slam poetry take off of the song lyrics. Then there is an often bizarre writeup about the song itself, or its singer, or composer, or a place it mentions. One song write-up was mostly a list of American pop songs that were originally foreign songs in other languages. On audio, Dylan himself does the slam poetry reading, while a cast of stars take turns reading the song writeups. Not Nobel quality, though you do get a little insight into how Dylan thinks about songs. I listened to the 2/5 of the songs I hadn't heard, or hadn't remembered, before I read the section on the song. It made the book more interesting, and I wouldn't have understood what was being written about otherwise.

View all my reviews

Review: Cinema Speculation

Cinema Speculation by Quentin Tarantino
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I enjoy movies and I really like reading about the movie business, but I’m not keen on horror. It’s odd that, while Tarantino really likes horror movies, he can talk about them and make his whole commentary interesting. It’s not just that the business side of horror movie making is a big part of what he talks about. It’s that he is just so interested, and has thought about these movies so much, that he has found the most interesting stories to tell, and he tells them with a kind of breathless fan-boy attitude that it sucks you into the book. I really enjoyed how he approaches this book in two aspects – first as a commentary and criticism of a few specific movies that he thought were key. The second aspect is to provide his personal background related (or not so much related) to seeing these movies, and growing up as a movie fan in general. Here, you get to hear about his diet of movies and who he attended them with, which theaters he went to, even how rowdy the crowd was. He has a way with getting you to see through his eyes. Listening to this audiobook was a lot like riffing on the topics of the day with college roommates, enjoying the opportunity to imagine after studying dry materials. Very interesting and entertaining, and I’d gladly read more like this from him.

View all my reviews